I’m a Denim-Loving Fashion Editor: 6 Jeans That Look Vintage But Actually Aren’t

I don’t have the statistics, but when it comes to vintage shopping, I’d argue that jeans are the most sought-after product. Even in my small circle of friends and fellow NYC editors, I hear all the time that people want to spend their free time vintage shopping on the Lower East Side to find the perfect lived-in jeans. Some even travel over 6000 miles to Tokyo or Paris just to shop at stores like The Parisian Vintage and Ragtag. While it sounds fun (what fashion person doesn’t want to shop whenever they can?), what people aren’t talking about is how expensive vintage jeans are these days, the expertise that’s required to navigate different eras of sizing and fabric composition, and the time it takes to sift through racks of clothing. Also, there are so many widely available jeans styles on the market that mimic the texture, color, and silhouette of vintage finds while still being new.

To prove that point, I took it upon myself to source the best vintage-looking jeans, try them on, and wear them around NYC. I looked to brands like Levi’s, AG, Agolde, Citizens of Humanity, and more, which are designing denim with a lived-in, relaxed aesthetic. Keep scrolling to discover the six jeans that provide the authentic look of a well-loved thrift-store find without the actual age. Thank me later.

Best Vintage-Looking Jeans at a Glance

• Best Overall: Gap Low Rise ’90s Loose Jeans ($53)
• Best Low-Rise Jeans: AG Sandra Jeans ($245)
• Best Straight-Leg Jeans: Mother The Lil Reifler Jeans ($268)
• Best Baggy Jeans: Agolde Vintage Loose Jeans ($258)
• Best Printed Jeans: Citizens of Humanity Anissa Jeans ($298)
• Best Bootcut Jeans: Levi’s 725 Heritage Jeans ($41)

Gap Low Rise ’90s Loose Jeans

My Review: Hailey Bieber is a vintage-denim lover. When she’s not wearing activewear, she’s donning jeans, specifically loose, low-rise vintage Levi’s sourced by Denim by Orlee. However, she’s recently been wearing Gap’s Low Rise ’90s Loose Jeans. She seriously can’t get enough of them, so when putting this story together, I knew I had to try them for myself to see if they looked vintage and actually fit well on a regular fashion person like me.

For those wondering whether they’re worth the purchase, the short answer is yes. These jeans feature a soft, semi-stretchy denim that lends an effortlessly loose fit. Since I need to copy everything Bieber does, I opted for her favorite wash: Dark Blue Indigo. While the color is darker in person, I still love them because they have that authentic fading characteristic of time-tested jeans.

Sizing Tip: Size down

Shop the jeans:

Agolde Vintage Loose Jeans

My Review: Agolde has a reputation for denim that masterfully captures a worn-in, lived-in aesthetic. While many fashion people are already familiar with popular silhouettes like the ’90s Pinch Waist and Low Slung Baggy, the brand has introduced a new contender for the ultimate vintage feel: the Vintage Loose. True to its name, the Vintage Loose is designed to be relaxed. What makes this pair particularly unique is its nontraditional approach to the low-rise trend. Although intended to sit low on the waist, the jeans actually feature a 12.75-inch rise—a measurement typically seen on high-waisted silhouettes. To fully embrace the vintage vibe and ensure the jeans sit correctly for that oversize, slouchy look, size up.

Sizing Tip: Size up if you want them to be low-waisted and baggy

Shop the jeans:

Mother The Lil Reifler Jeans

My Review: They say, “When you find something that fits you perfectly, buy it in every color,” so I’m taking that to heart with these Mother jeans. Designed in collaboration with model Paige Reifler, the Lil Reifler style combines the best elements of jeans from the ’70s, ’80s, and ’90s. It’s a mid-rise straight-leg silhouette with a slight kick-style hem that gives it a subtle bootcut-like appearance.

I first got Daydreamer, the lightest blue wash, in April. It features a vintage wash and lived-in look that perfectly balances the rigid, nonstretch denim. More recently, I added Starry Eyed to my collection, which is a ’90s-inspired rich black that reads as a deep blue thanks to the subtle fading. Now, I just need to add the medium blue and classic blue washes to my collection to have the full range.

Sizing Tip: Take your true size if you want a fitted look; size up for a baggy appearance

Shop the jeans:

AG Sandra Jeans

My Review: In case you missed it, skinny jeans are having a moment. However, I’m not fully ready to go back to the ultratight styles of the past, so I’ve been on the hunt for vintage-inspired jeans that look slim without a restrictive ankle while remaining relaxed through the leg. That’s very specific, I know. I finally landed on the perfect pair: the Sandra Jeans by AG. This style is described as low-rise straight, and I agree it sits perfectly low on the waist, but I’d argue it tapers a bit more after the knee than a traditional straight-leg silhouette. The light wash is so pretty, but what really gives the jeans that authentic vintage character is the pigment accents meticulously placed on the seams and creases. Beyond the looks, the material is what won me over. The cotton-and-lyocell blend feels like butter on the skin. There is one practical detail to keep in mind: the length. Unless you are 5’3″ or taller, you will most likely need to get them hemmed to achieve the right fit. After I get these tailored, I’ll be reaching for them repeatedly.

Sizing Tip: Runs true to size

Shop the jeans:

Citizens of Humanity Anissa Jeans

My Review: With clean lines and a subtle graphic edge, striped denim is an underrated way to tap into a vintage look without the need for classic blue fading. And there’s no better time than now to do so, as striped jeans are what all the cool girls are wearing this summer. While there are so many elegant styles from brands like Zara and Reformation, my favorite is the Anissa from Citizens of Humanity because of the versatile straight leg, relaxed low-rise waist, faded blue shade, and mix of thick and thin stripes. Even if you’re a minimalist dresser like me, you’ll love these jeans—I guarantee you.

Sizing Tip: Size down

Shop the jeans:

Levi’s 725 Heritage Jeans

My Review: When you think of vintage-looking Levi’s jeans, the brand’s 501 ’90s and Wedgie Bootcut styles probably come to mind first, and that’s not wrong. But since Levi’s is an expert in this category, there are many other styles to highlight, such as the 725 Heritage Jeans. This pair is a mid-rise silhouette with a slim fit and a ’70s-inspired leg-lengthening shape. The back pockets have cool old-school contrast stitching that adds a touch of style, and I love how they sit high on the waist to create a lifting effect.

Sizing Tip: Runs true to size

Shop the jeans:

Shop More Vintage-Looking Jeans